Other Federal League News-Click Here
Kahuna's Essay Column
October 1, 2016
There Goes The Neighborhood: In the past, we spent
a fair amount of time in this column discussing the relative
merits of Major League Baseball's replay system.
While I am of the mind that "getting the call right" is
important, I am bitterly opposed to any method of replay that
relies on challenges, or any other type of system with any other
arbitrary limits on how many calls might be reviewed. Rather, I
have always advocated that, if you are going to have a replay
review of umpire calls, there should be a fifth umpire, whose sole
function is to review all calls and make a fairly immediate
Even if baseball adopted this type of replay system, the use of
replay further erodes baseball tradition. There is no greater
example of this erosion than Major League Baseball's decision
to allow the "neighborhood play" to be open to review.
The neighborhood play, and its expert application by the most
savvy of middle infielders, is not only a time honored baseball
tradition, it is one of the little facets of the game that allows
the sport to remain a part of human expression and not the
techno-centric homogeny that organizations like the NFL strive to
The difference between baseball and football, at the highest
professional levels is sometimes similar to the difference
between a great local restaurant and an upscale chain. The local
place has its own vibe and feeling, and the chain tries to
replicate the same experience, regardless of where you find it.
Eliminating accepted oddities, such as the neighborhood play,
brings baseball one step closer to losing that special intimacy
that exists between the sports and the populace.
It seems to me that in an effort to maximize technology for the
purpose of getting all the calls right, we are sacrificing some of
the art of the game.
To drive this point even further home, the Major League Baseball
Rules Committee approved some changes last week, including a rule
which will allow a pitcher to intentionally walk a batter without
having to throw the pitches.
It is inconceivable to me how this new rule is supposed to enhance
What's next? Courtesy runners? Not having to run the bases after a
home run? Why not use a softball instead of a baseball, pitch
underhand, and let hitter use aluminum bats?
Which brings us to the suddenly hot topic of bat flipping.
Recently, there has been a lot of debate about bat flips, fist
pumps, and showing up the opponent.
One one hand, some people feel that bat flipping after a home run,
of fist pumping after a pitcher records a strikeout, are thing
that make the game more fun.
Really, I can't see how. If your team's player has just hit a key
home run, or if your team's pitcher has just worked his way out of
a jam with a big strikeout, and you need him to exhibit some
gratuitous show of emotion for you to enjoy the moment, I think,
it is safe to conclude, that you are not a baseball fan.
On the other hand, a big home run, or really any great
performance, is exciting on its own merit. It provides its own
punctuation, regardless of the (mostly choreographed) celebration
by the player involved.
Relevant Question Of The Month: Even though you have been
opposed to the wild card system in the past, don't you agree that
having extra teams in the playoffs is good for baseball?-G. D.
It depends on how you look at it.
From a business standpoint, yes, increasing the number of teams,
is beneficial to Major League Baseball. Fans of, otherwise,
mediocre teams are able to remain interested in the outcome of the
season longer. This leads to greater ticket sales, more TV
viewership, and, ultimately, greater revenue.
However, watching a bunch of barely over .500 teams lurch toward
the post-season on the backs of, something like, an unimpressive
12-15 record down the stretch, is not good baseball.
A team could stumble its way through the season, sneak in to the
playoffs as the second wild card, catch a few breaks in the
post-season, and win the World Series having won barely more than
they lost. All season.
That's not good baseball either.
Send your question for the Big Kahuna to:
Previous Big Kahuna Articles Can Be Found In The Big Kahuna Archive
Send mail to email@example.com
with questions or comments about this web site.
Web Site Copyright © Federal League Athletics,
2014. All Rights Reserved.